Well, I finally finished this post-Small Potatoes effort--don't you hate it when real life gets in the way of fanfic? Anyway, this is my attempt to deal with the awkwardness Scully's encounter with Eddie must have caused. And, for the record, Eddie's actions are, in my book and in Scully's, rape. Feedback is welcomed at this hellish AOL address or at my school address, but I won't be able to access it until August. RATING: PG-13 CLASSIFICATIONS: S, MSR KEYWORDS: Post-Small Potatoes, MSR DISCLAIMER: Scully, Mulder, and Eddie belong to MFAC, 1013, and Fox, not me. SUMMARY: Scully forces Mulder to discuss the ramifications of Eddie Van Blundht's attempted 'seduction.' DEDICATIONS: This one is for Tab, who I haven't talked to in a while and miss, and for Amy, who's visits have been chock full of fun and obsessing . CARVING OUT OF JEALOUSY Danielle Dupr_' I walked beside him, unsure of how to break the odd discomfort that shadowed our partnership for the past month. Searching my mind for the proper thing to say, I settled on the simplest. "I'm sure you don't need to be told this, Mulder," I spoke quietly, not turning to look at him. "But you're not a loser." I still couldn't figure out why he'd asked me to accompany him to see Eddie Van Blundht in prison. After all, he hadn't included me in anything unless absolutely necessary during the twenty-nine days since he'd burst through my door to find me about to kiss a man who, for all intents and purposes, was him. I can't even begin to describe the thoughts that ran through my head in the few seconds it took me to get out from under the impostor. Humiliation, anger, hurt, and disgust were among the top ten. After his initial shock, Mulder had snapped into his professional mode, cuffing Van Blundht while I called the local precinct. Mulder's words jolted me from my thoughts. "Yeah, but I'm no Eddie Van Blundht, either," he answered, fidgeting with his cuffs to avoid eye contact. "Am I?" I clenched my jaw, forcibly holding back the remarks threatening to tumble, unchecked, from my mouth. Although his words could be taken as an insult, his tone revealed true uncertainty. I longed to take his hand and tell him that, no, he wasn't Van Blundht because he didn't need to be. He was Mulder, the most important person in my life, and a wonderful man. But, as per our usual pattern of leaving things unsaid, I didn't speak until we reached the car. "Give me the keys," I demanded, holding out my hand. After a tense moment, our gazes locked. Mulder studied my face, then dug his keys out and dropped them on my palm, careful not to touch me. That's another thing that's changed since that fateful night. Mulder's casual touches have ceased. His hand no longer graces the small of my back, or my elbow, or even my shoulder. As irritating and proprietary as I once considered his actions to be, I sorely missed what little physical contact we used to have. I slid into the driver's seat, pausing to pull it forward, and slammed the door. As I started the car, Mulder slumped into the passenger side, turning his face towards the window. His body language practically begged for me to leave him alone, so I obliged during the drive, snapping the radio on. Before this rift of sorts, we'd never needed the radio. Instead, we used our drives to debate our latest case or where we would stop for dinner. Even the silence used to be comfortable, but now, it pulsed with unspoken words and thoughts to which neither of us possessed the courage to give voice. Mulder buried himself in his head, ignoring both the radio and my frequent glances with admirable ease. Not even a near miss with a two brunettes driving maniacally in a Toyota roused him from his fugue state. In fact, I parked at the curb in front of my apartment before he spoke. Turning his head towards me, yet staring past me out the window, he said, "Thanks for driving." I sat there and studied him, this man who I thought I knew so well. It's true that my own embarrassment and anger helped create this distance between us, but I was ready to hash it out so that we could go back to being partners in the truest sense of the word. Since all but the most rudimentary communication between us had ceased, I had no way of knowing if Mulder had reached the same point. With a slight nod, I pulled the keys from the ignition and stepped out of the car. Locking the door, I rounded the hood, watching Mulder from the corner of my eye. I could feel his quizzical gaze on me, but I merely kept walking. By the time he opened his door, I'd nearly reached the stairs. "Hey, Scully. Last time I checked, keys were required to drive cars." I forced the irritation off of my face, and glanced over my shoulder. "Come on in, Mulder. We need to talk." Not pausing to see if he followed, I opened the front door and proceeded to my apartment. I hadn't even finished unlocking the door when he caught up to me. "Scully, what's going on?" He asked, his voice suddenly full of fear. He leaned into my space and studied my face. Immediately, I knew he'd assumed that I had bad news about my tumor, and I raised my gaze to his. "Nothing like that, Mulder," I answered and he relaxed visibly. The tumblers turned, and I pushed the door open, glancing again at the new section of the door frame that didn't quite match the rest. I opened the door wide, crossing to the table behind my couch to check my answering machine for messages. The red light remained steady, and I dropped the car keys next to the phone before turning back to Mulder. He stood in the doorway, his eyes raking over every last detail of my living room and it hit me. He hadn't been back since that night. I gave myself a mental slap and stepped into his line of sight. "Are you coming in?" I could see his face harden into its mask as he held my gaze. "Can I sit on the couch?" He asked, sarcasm adding bite to the question. I flinched, then cursed myself for allowing him to get to me. "Sure," I answered, ignoring the double meaning. "Would you like something to drink?" Mulder shrugged out of his coat, tossing it carelessly on the chair near the door, then rounded the couch, sitting gingerly on the edge. Looking up at me from his new vantage point, he snorted. "I'm not really a big drinker, Scully. Got any wine?" Even though I knew why he was acting like a petulant ten year old, his words hurt. I raised my chin defiantly and narrowed my eyes slightly. "No," I paused, arching a brow and letting a touch of sarcasm lace my tone. "I do have some Absolut and I can probably rustle up some orange juice concentrate, but I was thinking more along the lines of water, iced tea, or Sprite." It was only after the words left my mouth that I remembered that long ago night that Mulder had forever linked iced tea to the sexual tension between us. My whole body tensed as I waited, sure he'd twist my words around to hurt me as I'd apparently hurt him. To my surprise, the tension drained from the lines of his body as he held my gaze. I watched his eyes soften in confusion. Finally, he spoke quietly "I'm sorry." I can count on one hand the number of times I've heard Mulder apologize, and only a couple of those times had been to me, so I was a bit shocked when I heard his words. After a moment's hesitation, I rounded the edge of the couch and sat in the white chair to the side. Even in my surprise, I consciously avoided sitting where I'd sat that night. I reached out and grasped Mulder's hand lightly. "It's okay. I'm sorry, too." Mulder's eyes widened, and I saw the hurt set in. Realizing he'd misinterpreted what I was apologizing for, I sighed. This was harder than I thought it would be. Sharing my feelings was not something I was good at, especially when the listener was Mulder, which was another reason I should've known it wasn't Mulder that night. Eddie had been so easy to talk to, yet I'd still believed he was my prickly, self-absorbed partner. Mulder leaned back into the cushions, his hand pulling from my grasp as he stared at the empty fireplace. I followed his gaze, wondering if his mind was replaying that night, too. Sighing, I bent forward, settling my elbows on my knees. After a long, tense moment, I gathered my courage and spoke, "Mulder, we need to talk about this." Mulder's jaw clenched, but he merely asked, "About what?" I rolled my eyes. Mulder was nothing if not an expert at evading intimacy of any kind. Turning my head, I pinned him with my gaze. "Mulder." His head fell back to the cushions and his eyes closed. I allowed him a moment to struggle with his demons before continuing, "You know what this is about." Finally, my words broke through his layers of protective shields and he sat up. His intense hazel eyes burned into mine as he spoke. "Yes, I do know what this is about," he conceded, his husky voice soft in the silence of my apartment. "But I think it's best that we pretend that night never happened." Anger flooded my body, "Best for who, Mulder? For you? So that you can ignore the elephant in the room for a bit longer? So you can keep pushing me away until our partnership is a memory? We've been pretending for the past month, and it's not working anymore." I bit off my tirade and crossed my arms defiantly. The ball was in his court. Mulder hesitated for a long, tense moment before he sighed, "You're right, Scully." The lines of his body relaxed as his gaze slid from mine to examine something fascinating just over my left shoulder. I allowed myself a small smile, "Could I get that on tape, Mulder?" My question elicited a surprised laugh from my partner, and I added another to my mental tally of the times I'd been able to make Mulder laugh. It didn't happen often. The serious tone of his next words pulled me out of my thoughts, "I don't know what you want me to say, Scully. The image of Eddie and you . . . " Finally, we were getting somewhere. His narrowed eyes still studied the wall behind me as his hands twisted a bit in his lap. I remained quiet, hoping he'd fill the silence with words. I didn't have long to wait. "I couldn't believe it," Hurt laced his husky voice, and his eyes jumped back to mine. "Four years we're partners, and you couldn't tell it wasn't me? Why is that, Scully?" Ouch. He'd gone straight for the heart of the matter. This time it was me who broke eye contact, ducking my head to study my hands. I paused to collect my thoughts, then spoke carefully. "I've asked myself that same question many times since that night," My gaze rose to his. "The only thing that makes sense is that I wanted so much for it to be you that I ignored any warning signs that it wasn't." Mulder's eyes widened noticeably, and I furrowed my brow in a silent question. After a moment, he asked softly, "What do you mean you wanted it to be me?" Realization dawned. My words could be interpreted two ways, and although he wasn't wrong, I was not ready to discuss that aspect of my feelings. I backpedaled quickly. "We rarely talk, and although I feel I know you well, there are some aspects of your life that I know next to nothing about. Sometimes I think it would be nice for us to just sit and talk." His face fell slightly, and his gaze skipped away from me. I sighed, wondering why our conversations were so full of unspoken and unfulfilled hopes. Mulder slumped back into the couch cushions, his feelings clearly hurt. After a moment of plucking listlessly at a pillow, he spoke defensively. "You can talk to me, Scully, you know that." I rolled my eyes. This was not a topic we needed to get into just yet. Mulder's intense involvement in our work left little time for the niceties of life, one of which was simple conversation between friends. But, I could find no way to explain this without it seeming like a personal attack. "I know I can talk to you about the important stuff, Mulder," I said in a conciliatory tone, hoping he'd accept my answer. Mulder's head snapped up and he pinned me with his hazel eyes. "What's that supposed to mean?" I suppressed the apprehension building in my stomach and concentrated on formulating an answer. After a moment, I spoke casually, "Just what I said--I can talk to you about the important stuff." Mulder rose, tension thrumming in the lines of his body as he paced to the window and looked out. His voice was bitter when he answered, "But you can't just sit and talk to me." I stood from the chair and approached him. Once at his side, I joined him in staring out the window at the blue house next door. Absently, I noted a hint of brown showing through the paint in the light of the waning sun. Turning my attention back to the man beside me, I opened my mouth to speak. Mulder's next words cut me off, "Is that why you were going to let him kiss you?" I froze, stunned that he'd actually verbalized the question that had been hanging over our heads for the past month. I searched my mind for an answer, but none was forthcoming. What could I say? That I wasn't going to let Van Blundht-as-Mulder kiss me? I couldn't even rationalize that one to myself, never mind to the man who'd kicked in my door in time to get an eyeful. After a lengthy pause, I decided that the truth, embarrassing though it may be, was the only way to go. Taking a deep breath and screwing up my courage, I answered, "Yes, I suppose it is." Although my eyes stayed on my neighbor's house, I remained focused entirely on Mulder as he stood there, motionless. Finally, he nodded once, then walked away. I didn't turn, but listened to his footsteps. The infuriating man was actually going to leave without another word. Spinning suddenly, I nearly yelled, "Mulder, where are you going?" He stopped in place, his back to me and his coat dangling from his left hand. "I don't really think there's anything more to say, Scully," he answered, his tone of voice resigned. I snorted, then marched determinedly to him. His head fell forward in defeat or irritation--I couldn't tell which--as I reached his side. "Oh, we've only scratched the surface," I said angrily, glaring up at him. Mulder tilted his head in my direction, but avoided my gaze. "What, are you going to list every other reason why you'd never kiss me?" He asked raggedly, the hurt in his voice squeezing my heart painfully. "Because I assure you, I can list them all myself. Can we save ourselves the time and the aggravation if I promise to go home and beat my head against the wall?" Mulder stormed toward the door, and it took me a moment to force my body to move. I caught his arm and spoke, "Mulder, that's not what--" "Do you have any idea what it's like to walk in on the one person you trust, only to see her about to do the wild thing with someone else?" He towered over me, eyes flashing. Even in my shock, I managed a bitter laugh, "So quickly we forget," I answered sarcastically, "Should I list them alphabetically or chronologically?" He rolled his eyes, "Scully, that's different. *I* didn't think they were some new-and-improved version of you." I shook my head, baffled by his illogical retort, "What are you talking about, Mulder? I thought he was *you*." He finally turned to me, his gaze pinning my in place as surely as his hands on my shoulders. "It doesn't matter, Scully. The only reason you let him get that close is because he didn't have my faults. You wanted *his* personality, not mine." I shook my head slowly. "That's not true," I answered. "The only reason I let him in the door is because I thought he was the man I trust and respect. I wouldn't have let anyone else that close to me, Mulder." As my words hung in the air, I realized I'd said far too much. My face slowly grew hot, and I hoped the blush wasn't too noticeable in the dimness of the gloaming. Mulder's hands loosened their grip on my shoulders as his eyes searched my face. "Scully," he spoke finally, a slight tremble in his voice, "What are you trying to say?" My throat suddenly closed up, disallowing words. I stared at him, taking in the badly disguised hope in his eyes and finally understood. He hadn't withdrawn from me because of discomfort with the fact that I'd almost kissed someone I thought was him, but because he'd wanted it to *be* him. Jealousy fueled his sudden need for physical distance between us, even though I doubt he had recognized it for what it was until this confrontation. Some unnamed emotion spread through me as a smile fought to curve my lips. Still unable to find the words, I allowed our silent communication to take over. After an intense moment of searing eye contact, I placed my hands on his biceps and slowly leaned up towards him. Mulder's beautiful hazel eyes widened slightly, and I heard his breathing alter slightly. His eyes dropped to my lips, and he bent his head. Slowly, slowly, I closed the distance between us, my gaze drawn to his full lips until they parted slightly. My eyes slid closed as our lips touched softly. Neither of us moved for a timeless moment, content with just the barest contact. Finally, Mulder's hands on my shoulders slid down my back, pulling me towards him. I swayed into him, tilting my head and increasing the pressure on his mouth. His full lips caressed mine, as my arms encircled his neck. My mouth opened on a sigh, and Mulder deepened the kiss. After several moments of bliss, I reluctantly pulled back a bit. Mulder groaned, then opened his eyes to meet mine, all insecurities about Van Blundht erased by our kisses. Gracing him with a small, seductive smile, I whispered, "*That's* what I was trying to say." Mulder's brow furrowed for a moment, and then he grinned at me. His hands left my back, sliding up and cupping my face. He kissed my forehead, then cocked his head to the side and smirked at me, "I'm afraid there may have been some interference with your message. I'm gonna need you to repeat that a couple of times to ensure that there's no misinterpretation on this end." His hazel eyes danced as he waited for response. I let a smile surface briefly, then arched a brow at him. "Only a couple of times?" I asked innocently. Mulder laughed softly, leaning his forehead against mine. "I knew there was a reason I fell in love with you," he answered playfully. Mulder pulled back slightly when he realized what he'd said, but I followed him, kissing him softly, yet passionately. I drew away when the tension receded from his body. Instinctively, I knew he needed me to lighten the moment. Giving him a tender smile, I spoke seductively, "You only want me for my body." Mulder closed his eyes on a moan. "Scully," he said, his voice husky. "If you want me to leave tonight, you've got to quit using that tone of voice." I grinned at him, "Who said I wanted you to leave?" Mulder's eyes lit up as he gazed down at me, lips curved upwards. He leaned down, his eyes dropping to my lips, but I evaded his kiss. A frown flitted across his features until I reached up and caressed his jaw. "I love you, too, Mulder," I said quietly, "I just thought you should know that." Mulder's smirk widened into a goofy grin, and I felt a matching smile splitting my own cheeks. THE END Did I mention that I love feedback? WinemaXF@aol.com